Michael Johnston (Baron "Bear" Bailey), Inde Navarrette (Nikki Freeman), Cooper Tomlinson (Ian), Megan Lawless (Sarah Harper), Andy Richter (Carter Harper), with Haley Fitzgerald (Viola), Darin Toonder (Harry), and Curry Barker (voice on the phone) Edited and Directed by Curry Barker.
Review:
Sure, let's do the new movie garnering attention that happens to be directed by a YouTuber.* Born and raised in Alabama, Curry Barker had met Cooper Tomlinson on the campus of NYFA Los Angeles and had a quick connection to where they made sketch comedy together for the channel "that's a bad idea". They made a few short films as well before making a film together for $800 with Milk & Serial, a found footage film that they decided would be best to put out on YouTube for their fans. Barker stated that he had an idea about an obsessed person and a relationship, but the wishing aspect came about by seeing an old episode of The Simpsons (specifically "Treehouse of Horror II", which involved a segment with a monkey's paw). The film was shot over a span of under four weeks while having a bit of re-shoots (such as including the opening scene or the scene where the brief confrontation scene after getting his hair cut in his sleep). It premiered originally at a midnight section of the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2025 and attracted enough attention to get Focus Features to acquire distribution rights in America. We've all seen a few things with the monkey's paw or with great desires of control such as The Twilight Zone's "The Chaser" or Tales from the Crypt (the 1972 segment "Wish You Were Here", or the 1991 episode "Loved to Death"). Or maybe the Wishmaster movies, or Wish Upon (2017). Well, maybe not everything (okay, I didn't see the latter two, but I'm sure someone did), but still.
It's a pretty good movie, which is a relief to me in hearing about a horror movie that garnered some attention that did in fact make it worthwhile to see in a movie theater (as opposed to ones that annoyed me, like Hereditary*). It's a movie for those who realizes the fine line that exists between "love story" and "romance" and also know how terrifying it really would be to have someone obsessed with you to along with the ramifications of believing that you could actually make it all work even when basically being on the edge of the cliff. Regardless of what you think is going to happen, the fear all comes in wondering when it will all bubble up to the surface. It probably helps that the One Wish Willow is just presented as a cheap enough trinket that isn't needlessly explained beyond having "customer service", honestly (there are moments that are pitch black in terms of humor, but the line between scary and funny is a pretty thin one, particularly in horror). Within the 109-minute runtime is a fairly suitable opening portion (yes, the diner scene was added in) before the inevitable hammer drops that makes it all the more tragic, namely in the idea that might as well be timeless in people who don't really know how to say what they mean (at least the lead guy doesn't ask Chat GPT what to do*).
Johnston makes for a capable lead focus to see all of this play out in basic pathetic nature, a man who doesn't really know what's so bad about being with him in the way he has set things. He basically ruins four lives (in one interview, Johnston noted he had a key contribution for the ending, incidentally) because of his own great selfishness, and Johnston handles it with such conviction that you want to keep seeing how he keeps digging himself further into the hole (anything to avoid rejection - note the fact that we don't really see this guy with anyone older than him besides his friend group). Navarrette was basically told to not play her role (after the wishing willow is used) as possessed, instead going for manipulation (one inspiration noted was Pearl [2022]). She runs the gamut in such an unnerving way of doing toxic lust, one who probably represents the ouroboros more than anything in the cynical nature of raw longing for someone at any cost. One instance sees them lurking in a corner, since the divide between Nikki and, well, the one trapped in a sunken place*, is pretty stark and that just makes the tension all the more harrowing besides just noting them using duct tape on a door. The chemistry between Johnston and Navarrette is unnerving in all of right places that goes to show that it isn't always a head-splatter that proves the most unsettling thing to experience in a film like this. The rest of the group fits the bill for what is needed in being swallowed in the vortex of ill-begotten ideas (the other thought that came about in the drunk Jenga scene is, hey, I want to be around that place). By the time the movie ends with such a good ol' downer*, you get plenty of satisfaction in seeing the perils of what can and what cannot be understood about decisions made for oneself in the name of "desire". As a whole, Obsession is a pretty entertaining horror movie, managing to evoke a good deal of scares into a simple enough premise of the perils that come from getting what you think you want and the fear in seeing it having an effect on everything around you. It's the kind of claustrophobic churning type of horror movie that will stick right with you by the time it all goes down.
Overall, I give it 8 out of 10 stars.
*Hey, Danny and Michael Philippou started out on YouTube, as was the case with Chris Stuckmann (Shelby Oaks) and Mark "Markiplier" Fischbach (Iron Lung). If I really wanted to look for YouTuber movies, it would actually start with Angry Video Game Nerd: The Movie or one by Brad Jones, because I really don't watch that many YouTube channels anyway. I head RedLetterMedia is fine?
*Ironically, I enjoyed Ari Aster's subsequent Midsommar a bit more than Hereditary. I will also say that Beau is Afraid has been on my back burner for a bit.
*Hey, fuck Chat GPT.
*Maybe not exactly a riff of Get Out (as shot near Barker's home), but one does wonder if there was even the tiniest inspiration from that.
*Apparently the film originally had an ending (text is light, highlight to read): where Nikki died. A request by a studio to reverse that basically ended up being more bleak, interestingly. I will say that the only way that things would've been ever more fucked for a downer ending would be if: Nikki awakens after the dream is ended but she finds out that she is pregnant.










