Once Upon a Time...When We Were Colored.

Review #1644: Once Upon a Time...When We Were Colored.

Cast: 
Al Freeman Jr (Poppa), Phylicia Rashad (Ma Ponk), Leon (Uncle Melvin), Paula Kelly (Ma Pearl), Charles Earl Taylor Jr. (Cliff, age 5), Salli Richardson (Miss Alice), Anna Maria Horsford (Miss Annie), Bernie Casey (Mr. Walter), Isaac Hayes (Preacher Hurn), Willie Norwood Jr (Cliff, age 12), Karen Malina White (Mary), Damon Hines (Cliff, age 16), Taj Mahal (Mr. Will), Iona Morris (Nila Fontaine), Phill Lewis (Sammy / Narrator), Polly Bergen (Miss Maybry), and Richard Roundtree (Cleve) Produced and Directed by Tim Reid.

Review: 
People can make their name anywhere in the industry of entertainment, and they can certainly try to branch out to other fields when it means getting a story told to wider audiences. Virginia native Tim Reid had set up for wanting to get into show business despite having studied business and marketing at Norfolk State University. In 1968, he started working at DuPont in marketing, but it was also the year that he met a salesman in Tom Dreesen. At the same time, Reid worked the marketing job while also developing a comedy act with Dreesen, and the comedy act (named Tim & Tom) was the first biracial comedy duo. The duo struggled for five years on the nightclub act before breaking up, but Reid would eventually find a chance with television, with his first regular role coming in 1978 with WKRP in Cincinnati. Roles in shows such as Simon & Simon and Sister, Sister followed alongside developing his own production company and writing/directing for television. This was the first film that Reid would direct, and it was an adaptation of Clifton L. Taulbert's 1989 novel of the same name, which was his memoirs about his experiences growing up in the Mississippi Delta as a youth in the 1950s (Taulbert is known for his consultant work, and he would also cite his experiences for a book involving lessons learned from the "porch wisdom" of his community). This is to date the only mainstream film that Reid has directed, as his next two efforts with Asunder (1999) and For Real (2003) were mostly constrained to festival and video showings (as compared to this film, which had funding from Black Entertainment Television (BET).

What we have is a film for the small-town folks at heart in a time where kinship and community had to deal with prejudice and intolerance as a youth grows up to be shaped by what he sees and hears before having to make a choice for himself on what to do with that in mind. There is plenty to look at when it comes to its attempts at a period drama that involve dozens of speaking parts and episodic movement that goes with a warm attempt at reaching audience that certainly has a big heart to its craftsmanship. Whether that ends up working enough to justify its 115 minute run-time is up to the viewer, particularly if they are curious for a film that is looking for calm within tension in a small town that might seem right for a project on television or presented to an audience for educational purposes (when comparing it to fellow rural period piece in The Color Purple, this is more tame). For a first-time director, it is an okay effort, one that shows promise for what it shows in the margins in terms of warmth within a troubling time, but it seems a bit too loose near its end to make its lasting point (at least in narration) sing its high notes with clarity. In short, where one thinks the tense moments will arise for its climax seems to only seep in like a half-grown flower rather than one in full bloom, one with a few punches to land when it comes to clean-cut memory weaving. Admittedly, it is the story revolving around the townsfolk that may prove the more endearing more so than the trio of actors playing the youthful focus. Freeman, an actor near the end of a four decade career with focus on television (such as One Life to Live), reins interest in terms of dignified timing, one that is interesting to view with the young folks around him with something useful to say or to view, which is made clear in one sequence involving him teaching his youthful relative about adapting to the times in reading certain prejudicial signs (like how to spell colored) or a tense parade involving the Klan. Rashad (making her film debut after first breaking into acting through the stage) does just as well, warm but aware of the surroundings that makes one seem right at home with its sprinkle of coming-of-age trimmings. The three actors for Cliff do okay, mostly because one will eventually settle into its groove involving family life even with adversity (that, or find something that doesn't seem as much like a Hallmark greeting card) and a decent enough kid to grow into it. Honestly, it's the folks around him that would probably be more interesting to follow, such as a sometimes-used Casey or Hayes, or more specifically with the confident Roundtree. By the time it ends, you'll find yourself with a little bit of a smile, even if you would have hoped for something a bit more in its actual movements, where its episodic nature can only go so far for a film with a mix of seasoned cast and fresh faces to go with a director looking to tell a story to a bigger audience in his first effort. For better or worse, it's an okay time, light and charming in its small-town features to showcase its vision of the old days without being suffocated by itself.

Next Time: George Tillman Jr enters the stage with his biopic of the first African American master diver in the United States Navy with Men of Honor. 

Overall, I give it 7 out of 10 stars.