Cast:
Sidney Poitier (Buck), Harry Belafonte (Preacher), Ruby Dee (Ruth), Cameron Mitchell (Deshay), Denny Miller (Floyd), Nita Talbot (Madame Esther), James McEachin (Kingston), Clarence Muse (Cudjo), Enrique Lucero (Indian Chief), Julie Robinson (Sinsie), and Lynn Hamilton (Sarah) Directed by Sidney Poitier.
Review:
Admittedly, first-time directors have a tough task upon them, and it is harder when one is also the star of the film as well. Joseph Sargent was the original director in mind for this film, which had a screenplay done by Ernest Kinoy (who had done the script for Brother John (1971), which had Poitier as star), although it had been refined by him and Poitier prior to production beginning. Poitier wasn't fresh to Westerns, as evidenced by his starring role in the 1966 Western Duel at Diablo, although he was second-billed next to James Garner. Sargent had directed a variety of television films and a handful of films such as Colossus: The Forbin Project (1970). However, Sargent was replaced early into production because Poitier (and Belafonte, a friend of Poitier ever since they met at the American Negro Theater years ago) felt that it was focused on just being a Western rather than one that honed to certain values near to them (Sargent wasn't hurt as a filmmaker - perhaps ironically, his 1972 production of The Man went from TV movie status to being released in theaters); note that within values of basically doing a buddy film in the clash of escape within hate is two prominent Native American characters being played by, well, the spouse of Belafonte and a man named Lucero. Poitier took over the production (as done in Mexico such as Durango) and did well enough that Columbia Pictures did not interfere in his filmmaking. Poitier would be a director for over a decade, directing such films as Uptown Saturday Night (where he starred with Belafonte again) and the highly successful Stir Crazy (1980) before closing it out with Ghost Dad (1990); Poitier died in 2022 at the age of 94.
It is a curious movie to say the least. There had been a handful of Westerns with black actors in prominent roles before this film, such as say, Two Gun Man from Harlem (1938), a musical, or ensemble films like 100 Rifles (1969) or Skin Game (1971 - incidentally, that featured Garner...billed before Lou Gossett). In fact, this wouldn't even be the only Western with black leads, as The Legend of Black Charley was released a few months after this film (incidentally this was also the same year that Black Rodeo, a documentary about an all-African American rodeo that happens to feature Muhammad Ali was released). Really this is probably a bit more familiar to those with experience enjoying Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969). It always helps to have film spring to mind actual history such as "Exodusters", which were African Americans that were moving along to places such as Kansas from states along the Mississippi River that started in 1879 (the film is actually set around the late 1860s while dealing with migration attempts out of Louisiana, but you get the idea). Liberation never felt so fun when it comes to the clash of men trying to deal with who they are with or without the gun. Poitier does pretty well in showing the vulnerability that comes with trying to be a man of one's word, which results in an engaging dynamic with Belafonte (a famed singer who acted in roughly over a dozen films). That clash of wills in terms of dogged truth and some form of faith (beyond just saying a huckster) work out well for gripping entertainment in 102 minutes. Scenes such as watching the first meet up with the natives and the two or one involving a distraction-shooting work best in that regard. Mitchell makes a suitable adversarial presence in malice that stokes that flame of fear desired for a film like this, which goes for Dee in quality timing as well. As a whole, the movie works best in the presentation attempt of showing the clash of wills between the races of people that each have belief in their way of life (whether that involves setting for Kansas, wanting to retain cheap labor through fear or living among the land as Natives) that works out on the basis of a confident filmmaker at work. It tells a useful story with two leads that had appreciation for the material put to them for a quality show that carved a useful place as a true Black Western.
Overall, I give it 8 out of 10 stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment