Redux: Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace.

Redux Review #142: Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace.

Cast: 
Liam Neeson (Qui-Gon Jinn), Ewan McGregor (Obi-Wan Kenobi), Natalie Portman (Queen Padmé Amidala), Jake Lloyd (Anakin Skywalker), Ian McDiarmid (Senator Palpatine / Darth Sidious), Anthony Daniels (C-3PO), Kenny Baker (R2-D2), Pernilla August (Shmi Skywalker), Frank Oz (Yoda), Ahmed Best (Jar Jar Binks), Oliver Ford Davies (Sio Bibble), Hugh Quarshie (Captain Panaka), Samuel L. Jackson (Mace Windu), Ray Park (Darth Maul, voiced by Peter Serafinowicz), Terence Stamp (Supreme Chancellor Finis Valorum), Keira Knightley (Sabé), Silas Carson (Nute Gunray), Brian Blessed (Boss Nass), Andy Secombe (Watto), and Lewis MacLeod (Sebulba) Written and Directed by George Lucas (#113 - Star Wars and #141 - American Graffiti)

Review: 
Countdown to 150 Reviews, 10, 9, 8...
Well, it has now been 20 years since the release of this film, the first of the three Star Wars prequel films. Fans may remember the revised editions of the Original Trilogy reviews (originally published 3/30-4/1, 2012) back in 2016, in light of Star Wars: The Force Awakens being released months earlier. I figured it was time to revise some admittedly okay reviews (original publish date of 5/19-5/20, 2012) right before Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker comes out. I hope you enjoy these reduxes. 

Review: 
It goes without saying that Star Wars is one of the biggest media franchises of pop culture. It has transcended film, television, and beyond over the decades - the original trilogy is still beloved by many, whether from people who seeked it out upon original release or found it playing somewhere on their screen in the present day. Return of the Jedi was the last of these films for 16 years, with Lucas not being inspired to do further films of his saga until the advent of CGI led him to believe it could help him do what he felt was needed. The result proved polarizing, especially in the age of a growing Internet - and age doesn't really help make this film seem too much better. This is a film that bears more on spectacle and details than a fully developed adventure. Perhaps Lucas fared best when he had at least one other writer trying to guide story ideas into something more than just an assortment of old arch-types and myths. The space opera has now shifted into one with mixes of action and politics - which makes for a somewhat stilted result. Like before, there are plenty of creatures and worlds to look at, even if it seems a bit less involving to stick for. I appreciate the effects for what they try to deliver, since they hold up well for 1999 - but wondering what is a blue/green screen and what isn't does get a bit distracting sometimes. The story seems spread too thinly, distracted over whether to be a movie about the Republic or Anakin, spending too much time to really drive itself forward. To say nothing of the logistics of electing a queen at 14, or midichlorians (which is still something to ridicule even with the dawn of a further trilogy), or referencing things from the previous films (did you know who built C-3PO? Weird, I know), and so on. Making fun of these aspects is more interesting to do while watching the film rather than spend a paragraph writing, one must say. The film does fine with spectacle pieces like the pod race sequence or the Darth Maul duel, but the former verges on meandering and the latter is nearly distracted from its other battle at the same time to have the right impact. With all of these characters (new and familiar), only a select group seem truly necessary, but the dialogue doesn't give them many favors. The trilogy is meant to be a tragedy of Anakin Skywalker, and yet the first film can't really plant many seeds to make that start to bloom, perhaps since the initial focus is on a kid (after all, Lucas moved his age from initially being 12 to 9 to try and fit the effect of him separating from his mother better). It didn't need to be a rehash with him being a young adult like Luke, but Lloyd is fledged with an unenviable task of playing an eventual Darth Vader in only one go. Having just one actor (and a change in pace, no less) for three films might have made them roll with more impact - at least we would have been spared a kid Anakin asking someone if they are an angel.

In a sea of interesting acting choices, it should only prove fair to have them seem routine behind some sets and screens. Neeson seems a bit too pallid to evoke much drama, with his final fate not having as much impact as it likely could have. McGregor doesn't quite have his familiar role pinned down here, and the lack of a dynamic between him and his future student in Anakin doesn't help much. Portman is hindered more by a ridiculous decoy plot than anything, but at least she does make some sort of curious impression. Lloyd doesn't quite have the conviction to make this role work, but how can anyone turn dialogue such as "Now this is podracing" really work (while being on a starfighter - long story) without ridicule? Any time with him and Portman is just weird in general. McDiarmid does well with playing the subtle kingmaker of his own doing without hitting a snag. August is quietly effective, even when occasionally lost in the spectacle background. Best plays a role that Buster Keaton would likely laughed off as too clownish with effort - it may not work out well, but at least he isn't the only fault present. The others (including a criminally underused Stamp) are pretty forgettable, and Darth Maul proves to be a fair but not too inspiring threat. Obviously the real threat is supposed to be the bigger one to look into (even if you already know who said threat is), but it only served to make for a trilogy of cut-scene quality adversaries. The droids don't prove too imposing, either, just big stick-looking things to fill the screen. By the time it gets to its climatic battle sequences, it proves to be a glut of overload, though the Maul fight is a bit nice. At least the lightsaber fights stick out for their attempts at finesse. In the end, the movie is a mish-mash of old story types, a dash of hubris, and ultimately something ridiculous to behold for each generation of fans, old and new. Some can rush to defend it for its quirks, and I understand that basis all the same - to me, this is an average adventure compounded as a disappointing Star Wars film.

Overall, I give it 6 out of 10 stars.